If you are as adventurous as I am, then I am sure you are gearing up for the exciting ongoing ice-fishing season. Ice fishing is one of the most popular sports that will surely test your limits of braving the extreme cold weather. To protect yourself from the cold air, moisture, and ice, you will need the ice fishing boots that do provide not only the utmost comfort and warmth but also durability and an excellent grip to make your adventures easier.
So, if you are looking for some helpful advice about buying the best ice fishing boots, then look no further, as I bring to you my tried and tested purchase guide, as well as my top recommended dry boots for ice-fishing. I have done the lion’s share of the work, using my many years of experience and knowledge to assemble a list of great cold weather boots and the considerations you should be mindful of when purchasing ice-fishing boots.
Ice Fishing Boots Buying Guide And The Top Consideration To Keep In Mind
My ice fishing buying guide is designed to help you navigate the somewhat confusing online market that offers a wide variety of boots at every price point. Here are my top considerations that you should be mindful of when buying your ice boots:
Insulation
When I am comparing different ice boots online, I always consider the type of temperatures I will be using the boots in, which helps me determine the level of insulation the boots are going to need. Ice fishing boots typically come with different levels of insulation. The rule of thumb is that colder temperatures require higher insulation to maintain the right level of warmth and comfort. Unique material like the 3M Thinsulate is specifically designed to offer ample warmth without added weight. Other insulation materials like fleece and wool add a comfortable paddle but are much heavier.
Waterproofing
Your ice-fishing boots will also need an appropriate level of waterproofing to protect your feet from the cold moisture. To avoid having aching, cold, wet feet, and frostbitten toes, it is essential that you invest in a pair of waterproof ice fishing boots, which will ensure that your feet remain dry.
Size
Typically, like most people, I wear my ice-fishing boots with a pair of thick warm socks. Therefore, when purchasing dry boots, I choose a size that will comfortably accommodate the additional layer of socks for a comfortable fit.
Traction
One of the essential considerations for ice-fishing boots is traction because it enables you to walk on slippery ice without slipping and falling. Well-made outsoles provide ample traction that will ensure that you can stand, walk and remain steady on ice.
Removable Liners
The convenience of having removable liners in my ice-fishing boots is always a great advantage. You can easily remove the lining of your boot, which allows them to air out the moisture and odor that has accumulated throughout the day and be clean and fresh for use the next day.
Related Article: 8 Best Spinning Rods for Trout Fishing
Best Ice Fishing Boots – Our Picks 2020
No products found.
1. Muck Boot Men’s Arctic Pro Hunting Boot
The Arctic Pro hunting boots for men from the renowned dry boot brand Muck Boots are one of the warmest ice-fishing boots I have tested. Muck Boots has specifically designed them to be comfortable and warm, and this is achieved thanks to an 8mm Neoprene layer, combined with a fleece liner and 2mm thermal foam.
The combination of these insulation materials, the boots were able to keep my feet warm even when the temperature below minus 60-degrees Fahrenheit. Despite being adequately warm, the boots are also lightweight, which makes it easy to walk around in for long periods. The tall design of the boots also helped in keeping the legs warm and cozy.
On the other hand, these boots offer an average level of traction because the grips on the soles aren’t deep enough. The grips of this Hunting Boot have been designed for flat, stable ice and snow terrain, and are great for long walks.
Pros & Cons
Pros
- Comfortably warm
- Easy maintenance
- Suitable for long walks
- Great waterproofing
Cons
- Lackluster traction
- The tall design might be unsuitable for short men
Check Price
No products found.
2. Kamik Men’s Greenbay 4 Cold-Weather Boot
The Greenbay 4 boots from Kamik offer a right combination of insulation, waterproofing, traction, and comfort for ice fishing and other outdoor activities in the snow. Kamik has over 100 years of experience in manufacturing cold-weather boots and liners. Experts around the world trust Kamik for their high-quality trust products and the Greenbay 4 boots are no exception.
In my experience, the boots’ most significant feature is the durable and flexible sole used that makes walking on ice and through snow easier. Deep grips provide an excellent level of traction on the footing that will stop you from slipping on ice.
The cold rating of Greenbay 4 is below 40 degrees Fahrenheit, which is perfect for ice fishing. The highly durable nylon shell has a warm felt liner that is removable and quick drying.
The 15-inch height of the boot allowed me to walk in deep snow, the lace-lock snow collar kept the feet warm, while the Velcro strap ensured a snug fit.
Pros & Cons
Pros
- Fits Snugly on feet
- High level of traction
- Lightweight
- Waterproof thanks to nylon shell
Cons
- Not suitable for people with wide feet
- Might not accommodate over one pair of socks
Check Price
No products found.
Related Article: The Best Fishing Reels – Detailed Reviews & Guide
3. Muck Boot Arctic Sport Rubber High-Performance Men’s Winter Boot
The Arctic Sport Rubber High-Performance boots from Muck Boots are some of the best ice-fishing boots, in my opinion. These highly practical boots have 2mm neoprene for maximum ease and flexibility.
The durable material offers excellent waterproofing, shock absorption, and heat retention. Neoprene also has the ability to fit the contours of your feet, which increases comfort. Thanks to the combination of materials used, including the rubber soles, the boots are lightweight and suitable for longer use.
As I mentioned before, the rubber soles of the boots have many advantages, including excellent traction with rugged molded lugs for great grip on uneven and slippery terrain. Furthermore, the rubber shell that extends above the ankle provides added waterproofing and heat retention. The fleece lining keeps the feet warm and comfortable. The high design of the boots also plays a role in keeping feet warm.
Pros & Cons
Pros
- Great waterproofing
- Lightweight sole
- High level of traction
- Shock absorbent
Cons
- High design suitable for tall people
- Average insulation
Check Price
No products found.
4. Columbia Men’s Bugaboot Plus III
The Bugaboot Plus III from Columbia is an ankle-high, durable, lightweight all-weather boot that offers the perfect amount of insulation for ice fishing in below 15 degrees Fahrenheit temperature.
Made from 100% leather and textile and weighing around 200grams, these boots are great for long-distance walks in snow and ice. The 200g synthetic insulation kept my feet adequately warm throughout use. Columbia has used Omni-heat reflective liner in the Bugaboot Plus III, which works amazingly well to retain heat and keeping the moisture out.
Priced just under $150 is excellent for all weather because of the Techlite shell membrane that increases durability and practicality. The lightweight midsole of these boots provided me with long-lasting comfort, superior cushioning, and ample shock absorption. The traction of these boots is exceptional and probably one of the best in my experience. The lug pattern on the soles allowed me to walk comfortably on ice and packed snow, as well as mud without worrying about slipping or sliding.
The Columbia Men’s Bugaboot Plus III is truly a premium quality cold-weather boot.
Pros & Cons
Pros
- Great insulation
- Comfortable
- Waterproof
- Great value for money
- Great traction
Cons
- Stiff design
- Bulky feel
Check Price
No products found.
5. Kamik Men’s Nationplus Boot
Kamik Men’s Nationplus Boots are my favorite traditional Pac boots! I have worn them for months, and I have never had any complaints with neither their design nor their protection. What I love about these best ice fishing boots is that they have a 100% leather and rubber waterproof outer and a 200g Thinsulate insulation inner liner.
Although you may think that a 200g insulation level boot would not provide enough protection in freezing weather conditions, that’s not the case! I have tried Kamik Men’s Nationplus Boots in below-freezing temperatures. And I must say that I was impressed by its tall shaft and platform design with a moisture-wicking lining that kept my feet and legs warm and cozy for the entire day.
Pros & Cons
Pros
- Excellent traction
- The rustproof Speed Lacing system
- Waterproof outer and inner
- Comfortable for long wear
- Thin and warm lining
Cons
- Feel heavy
- Requires design improvements
Check Price
No products found.
Read More About Fishing: Best Fishing Kayak To Buy in 2020
6. Sorel Men’s Conquest Boot
Sorel Men’s Conquest Boot is by far the most stylish looking ice fishing boot that I have ever tried. But do you know the best part? Sorel Men’s Conquest Boot does not only look good, but it is an excellent boot when it comes to comfort and built quality. Sorel Men’s Conquest Boot is made with 100% leather and synthetic material with a 4-inch tall shaft, rubber sole, large boot opening, a snow collar, and a medium height heel.
Sorel Men’s Conquest Boots are hands down the best ice fishing boots if style, warmth, protection, and comfort all are equally important to you. If you want the ice-fishing boots for temperatures less than -40 degrees Fahrenheit, than the Sorel Conquest waterproof leather boots with 400-gram Thinsulate Ultra insulation are an excellent option for you.
Pros & Cons
Pros
- Stylish and modern-looking design
- Durable waterproofing
- Impressively comfortable
- Excellent build quality
- Good insulation
- Available in other colors
Cons
- Complaints about material quality
- Too heavy for regular use
Check Price
No products found.
7. Baffin Men’s Wolf Snow Boot
Baffin has 25 years of trusted experience in manufacturing insulated and non-insulated footwear products. So, when it comes down to recommending the best ice fishing boots, Baffin is one of the brands that I trust the most. Baffin boots are reliable, comfortable, durable, and long-lasting, and Baffin Men’s Wolf Snow Boot is no exception!
Baffin Men’s Wolf Snow Boots are made with a 100% Leather and textile, 11-inch tall shaft, and a 1.5-inch heel. The best feature of Baffin Men’s Wolf Snow Boot is its Five Layers Inner Boot System that provides superior warmth in extremely cold weather conditions without making the boots too heavy.
Although I did not experience sizing issues, and I was lucky enough (or experienced enough) to make the best selection for myself. However, according to other ice-fishing boots reviews, many people have complained about the boots being too tight! So, I would highly recommend you to do your own research to ensure that you select the perfect size.
Pros & Cons
Pros
- Durable built quality
- Snow collar lock
- Comfortable regular wear
- Lightweight
Cons
- Sizing issues
- No waterproofing
Check Price
No products found.
8. Kamik Men’s Canuck Cold Weather Boot
Kamik is by far the best ice fishing boots brand! I have previously mentioned another of my top favorite Kamik Men’s Cold Weather Boot, and I cannot conclude my list without mentioning my most trusted Kamik Canuck Ice Fishing Boots.
These ice-fishing boots are made with 100% Fabric with a rubber sole. Kamik Canuck is 1000 Denier waterproof nylon – featuring a durable rubber shell at the foot and the adjustable bungee cords at ankle and opening. Kamik Canuck also features an 8mm removable Zylex liner – perfect for optimum comfortable & warm, and easy cleaning.
There are a few complaints about sizing and the overall bulkiness of the Kamik Men’s Canuck Cold Weather Boot’s design. However, I have worn these Kamik Men’s Canuck fishing boots for years, and they have never failed to provide me outmost comfort and warmth during my long ice fishing trips. So, I would most definitely recommend these budget-friendly ice-fishing boots.
Pros & Cons
Pros
- Easy to clean
- Removable lining
- Flexible and durable built quality
- Slip-resistant tread
- Lightweight design
- Good value for money
Cons
- Issues with sizing
Check Price
No products found.
Verdict
So there you have it! Now you know the top 8 ice-fishing boots. I hope that my ice fishing boots review makes it easier for you to select the perfect ice-fishing boots that fit all of your requirements. Make sure that you read the buying guide and the FAQs to ensure that you make the best buying decision.
You might also like: Fisherman Gift Ideas For Any Budget
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Do I need special ice fishing boots? Or I can wear my regular winter boots for ice fishing?
It is never recommended to wear your regular winter boot for ice fishing. Why? Because there is always a risk of fatal injuries due to lack of traction and/or frostbite.
Ice-fishing boots are specifically designed to protect your feet from extreme cold weather conditions. Special ice fishing boots are waterproof, well-insulated, weatherproof, and they provide enough traction to protect you from injury.
With proper ice fishing gear – specifically ice-fishing boots, you will always be well protected, and you will be able to enjoy long hours of ice fishing trips with utmost comfort.
2. What are the best material, levels of insulation, and grade of insulation?
The best material, level of insulation, and grade of insulation wholly depend on the temperatures you will be most of the time. When it comes to choosing the best material, I usually recommend pre-treated synthetic material or leather.
For autumn and spring mild cold temperatures, ice fishing boots with a 200-gram level of insulation is sufficient; however, for freezing temperatures, I would recommend at least 400-gram insulation.
Higher grades of insulation would make your ice-fishing boots heavier. So to make sure that you invest in the ice fishing boots, you should be well aware of your requirements and the usual weather condition/temperatures.
3. How important is it to find the correct ice fishing boot size?
Choosing the correct size can be a bit tricky. But on the other hand, I cannot emphasize enough on the importance of wearing the perfect sized ice fishing boot. Accurate sizing does not only ensure optimum comfort, but it is also essential for robust protection. Compromising on the size should never be an option if you want to invest in the ice fishing boots.
4. Do ice fishing boots have to be waterproof or water-resistant?
It depends on your requirements; if you need the ice-fishing boots for professional use, and you are going to be in deep snow for long hours, then you should only consider 100% waterproof ice fishing boots.
However, if your requirements are different and you only need ice fishing boots for temporary use, and you are not planning to walk in deep snow, then you can do with ice-fishing boots that are water-resistant.
5. Are Crampons necessary for all ice-fishing boots?
Well, the answer to this question depends on the type of the sole of the ice fishing boot you own or planning to purchase. If the sole provides sufficient grip/traction, then you would not require crampons. However, I would recommend you to keep a pair of crampons in your ice fishing gear, just-in-case you need that extra grip while standing or walking on very slippery ice.
Related Article: Top 9 Ice Fishing Gloves and Buying Guide For 2020
